Rabbi Yosef Blau: A Reaction to Rabbi Motti Elon's Public Speech


Note from Tzedek-Tzedek: Rabbi Yosef Blau is the mashgiach ruchani at Yeshiva University and its affiliated rabbinical school Yeshivas Rabbeinu Yitzchal Elchanan. Rav Blau has been active in helping survivors of abuse in the Orthodox community, including cases involving rabbis and teachers. Rav Blau has kindly agreed to offer his insights to Tzedek-Tzedek regarding the case in Israel of Rabbi Motti Elon, and in particular Rav Elon's speech last week, available in its entirety at: http://www.inn.co.il/TV/Cat.ashx/0/180107.

A REACTION TO RABBI MOTY ELON’S PUBLIC SPEECH
By Rabbi Yosef Blau
The Israeli court system will determine Rabbi Moty Elon’s guilt or innocence of the charges against him. His public speech in Migdal will not affect that determination. However the speech challenged the credibility of Takana, the forum set up by prominent rabbis, psychologists and legal experts to respond to accusations of improper sexual behavior by rabbis and Jewish educators in the Orthodox community. Rabbi Elon accused the forum of making up charges against him and improperly influencing the legal process. He also announced starting a new yeshiva based on his followers in Migdal. To show his disdain for his critics he is calling it the yeshiva of love.

Elon’s charisma and control of his followers were apparent from the onset. The video began with his leading them in religious song, establishing him as the rebbe. Throughout he not only claimed innocence, but cast himself as righteous and a martyr. Facing the difficulty that he accepted leaving his position as rosh yeshiva of Yeshivat Hakotel and stopped his other projects; Rabbi Elon claimed that he wanted to prevent a chilul Hashem although innocent of all charges. For his supporters the implausibility of this explanation is irrelevant. Their loyalty overcomes any skepticism. I have learned from observing similar situations in America that a charismatic leader does create such trust in his disciples.

He reduced the entire structure of Takana to a small group of power-hungry individuals who mislead the major rabbis to believe the false allegations. He quoted snippets of conversations that supported his description of events although he never clarified what the original complaints were and what exactly occurred when he was interviewed by the forum. Behavior that would not be considered acceptable when done by others was justified as his way of showing love (pure and holy) for his pupils.

I have no direct knowledge of what actually happened but years of involvement with comparable situations in America led to hearing echoes in his speech of what I have heard numerous times. The popular and charismatic leader accuses others of being jealous of his success and manipulating young people to think they were abused. This dismissal of many rabbis and professionals is not questioned by followers who have been convinced that their rabbi is unique. In my experience this scenario has never corresponded to reality. For some true believers no proof will suffice to cause them to lose faith. Unfortunately it is faith in a man disguised as faith in Hashem and Torah.

Comments

  1. Jack7 November 2011 at 19:54

    Rabbi Blau is a true hero - he has worked valiantly for many years to protect the children of Israel!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yocheved Golani8 November 2011 at 09:38

    I watched Elon's "speech" and spotted numerous problems with his alleged authenticity. A journalist who's loooong appreciated my inner Bullshit-O-Meter, I noticed that he lacked sorrow, sadness and regret that any of the accusers suffered for some reason or another, and brought up sexual abuse charges of all things. Elon exhibited contempt for his accusers, Takana and the public, invoking self-serving kedusha with the singing (oh he's so willing to take the honey with the sting! Too willing). Nifty manipulative move, among others he made.

    Here's the caveat for his listeners to heed: The most important thing in communication is to hear what isn't being said. - Peter F. Drucker

    ReplyDelete
  3. J.A.M.10 November 2011 at 12:13

    My BS meter went off so strongly after the first 3 minutes that I had to turn it off. I hope that young man that he kissed was his son, and not a student.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Marrying a Soloveitchik

Image
Mazaltov! My nephew, Gedaliah Kestenbaum married Devori Soloveitchik in Jerusalem last week. Gedaliah has married into rabbinical aristocracy .    Devori is the daughter of  Rabbi Yitzchak Zev Soloveitchik, and the grand-daughter of Rabbi  Meshulam Dovid (Reb Dovid) Soloveitchik , who is Rosh Yeshiva of Yeshivat Brisk (one of the two) in Jerusalem . The Soloveitchik's are a rabbinical dynasty descended from Rabbi  Yosef Dov (HaLevi) Soloveitchik (The "Beis Halevi") and his son Rabbi  Chaim Soloveitchik ("Reb Chaim Brisker"). Rav Chaim's sons Rabbi  Yitzchak Zev (Reb Velvel) Soloveitchik ("The GRIZ" The Brisker Rov) and Rabbi  Moshe Soloveitchik seem to have gone in different hashkafik directions. Whereas Reb Velvel's descendents are predominantly right wing hareidim, Rav Moshe's branch are leaders in the Modern Orthodox/National Religious hashkafa – most notably Rav Joseph Ber Soloveitchik ("The Rav")
Read more

Hoax Letter Sent to Synagogue

Image
            (Beis Tefillah Synagogue, Ramat Beit Shemesh) The following hoax letter has been sent to members of the Beis Tefillah Synagogue board of management, as if it was written by Rabbi CM [ed. name respectfully withheld] who serves as their rabbi: I think that as long as David Morris sets policy for L.A [ed. Lema'an Achai ], and is their public face,  I will not allow L.A. to use the Shul for fundraising purposes. This will change if: 1)David M apologizes publicly for stating,and insinuating again and again(in many forums,but especially in his childish Tzedek Tzedek blog) that , as a group ,  "Rabbis" (of RBSA ) are guilty of aiding and abetting and enabling child molesters.(And that of course that leaves LA to come to the rescue of our children.) OR IF  2)LA  publicly , clearly,and unambiguously disavows such statements .They must say--we clearly,and unambiguously ,disavow  statements or blogs which say or imply that  Rabbis  of RBSA (as a group ) aid or a
Read more